Y'all ready to become a blade-collecting legend in the Wild West? ðĪ As a die-hard RDR2 player with over 500 hours in the saddle, I'm here to spill the beans on every single knife hidden across this masterpiece of a game. Forget just skinning deer â these bad boys tell stories of civil wars, vampire hunts, and bone-chilling mysteries! From Arthur's trusty default blade to John's sleek upgrade, tracking down all seven isn't just about completionism... it's about becoming the most feared (and stylish) outlaw on the frontier. Trust me, nothing feels better than pulling out that Ornate Dagger during poker night in Valentine and watching the whole table sweat bullets. ð
ðŠ Hunting Knife: Your Ride-or-Die Companion
This ain't just a knife â it's Arthur's signature tool! You start with it in Chapter 1, and unlike your favorite hat, this one won't vanish after a tumble down a cliff. Perfect for silent takedowns or skinning perfect pelts. Bored with the basic look? Head to any Gunsmith and pimp it out with engravings, carvings, or even gold metals. Pro tip: I always engrave mine with wolf motifs for that extra intimidation factor!
ðĶ Antler Knife: A Grisly Trophy
Wanna feel like a true mountain man? Ride northwest to Hanging Dog Ranch in Big Valley. Near the broken wagon, you'll find a hunter and grizzly bear locked in eternal combat. Loot the hunter's corpse for this unique antler-handled blade. It's macabre but oh-so-satisfying â like claiming victory from a draw! People Also Ask: "Does the Antler Knife do extra damage?" Nah, but it looks savage in cutscenes.
âïļ Civil War Knife: History in Your Hand
Head to Fort Brennand in Roanoke Ridge for this rusty relic. Used by a Confederate soldier during America's bloodiest war, this bowie knife screams 1865 energy. That D-shaped handguard? Pure vintage. Don't expect shine though â the patina tells its story. Fun fact: I once scared off O'Driscolls just by brandishing this during a saloon brawl!
ðĶī Jawbone Knife: Paleontology Payoff
After finding 30 dinosaur bones (yes, THIRTY!), meet Deborah MacGuiness at her tent. She'll gift this "Stegosaurus jawbone" knife... except it's clearly a coyote's choppers. Still, as a completionist, I treasure this wonky reward. Display it proudly at camp â Dutch always side-eyes mine!
| Knife Comparison | Damage | Rarity | Best For |
|---|---|---|---|
| Hunting Knife | â â âââ | Common | All-purpose |
| Antler Knife | â â âââ | Rare | Stealth kills |
| Civil War Knife | â â âââ | Epic | Historical flex |
| Jawbone Knife | â â âââ | Legendary | Collector's pride |
âïļ Wide-Blade Knife: Murder Mystery Evidence
Deep in Beryl's Dream mine near Mount Shann, this chunky blade's stabbed into some poor soul's back. No rewards, just creepy atmosphere. But for true crime junkies like me, it's essential! Bring a lantern â that collapsed tunnel's darker than Micah's soul. People Also Ask: "Can you solve the murder?" Sadly no... but I headcanon it was a cheating gold prospector!
ð§ Ornate Dagger: Missable Masterpiece
SAVE YOUR GAME BEFORE THIS! In Saint Denis, find five cryptic clues (church walls, alleys...) to trigger a vampire encounter. Kill him and LOOT IMMEDIATELY â this gold-handled beauty disappears forever if missed. The ritual carvings? Chef's kiss. I keep mine displayed in John's later chapters as a trophy.
âĻ John's Knife: An Epilogue Upgrade
When you switch to John post-main story, notice his sleeker clip-point blade? It's not just cosmetic â that tapered tip makes skinning cougars feel smoother. Customize it at gunsmiths too! I always add eagle engravings to honor Arthur. People Also Ask: "Can Arthur get John's knife?" Nope, it's exclusive to our beloved rancher era.
So there you have it, partners â every knife mapped out! Whether you're a completionist chasing 100% or just want to shank revenue agents in style, these blades transform RDR2 from great to legendary. Now saddle up, grab that metal detector, and start hunting! After all... in a world of outlaws and vampires, a good knife isn't just a tool â it's your story. ðĨ