Y'all ever notice how every epic game has those unspoken commandments? Like how we instinctively save Minecraft dogs or boop the Pig's snoot in Dead by Daylight? Well, after replaying Red Dead Redemption 2 in 2025, I've realized this masterpiece has its own sacred rules too—cardinal sins that'll make any true gunslinger shudder. These aren't just gameplay tips; they're about honoring Arthur Morgan's soul in a dying Wild West. Break ’em, and you’re disrespecting the whole dang narrative Rockstar painstakingly crafted.
🔫 Sin 1: Freeing Micah in Chapter 2? Absolutely Not!
Seriously, why would you?! Micah Bell isn't just annoying—he's pure snake oil in human form. That jail stint in Strawberry? A divine gift! Most of us agree: leaving him rotting behind bars maximizes Chapter 2’s golden era. The gang’s vibes at Horseshoe Overlook? Chef's kiss 💯. No Micah means no toxic rants, no bullying little Jack, and no poisoning Dutch’s mind. Freeing him early? That’s like inviting a rattlesnake to a picnic.
People Also Ask: "Why do players despise Micah so much?" Simple: he’s the tumor killing the gang from within. His journal entries alone prove he’s been scheming since Colter!
💰 Sin 2: Aberdeen Piggy Bank Exploit on Your First Ride
Okay, I get it—Tammy and Bray’s farm lets you stash Arthur’s cash for John later. Clever? Sure. But using it before Arthur’s final mission? Nah, partner. You’re robbing yourself of that raw, emotional parallel: starting from zero as John, just like the man himself rebuilding his life. That epilogue grind hits different when you ain’t swimming in inherited gold.
| First Playthrough | New Game+ |
|---|---|
| Embrace the poverty 😭 | Bank heist away! 💸 |
| Feels canonically right | Pure chaotic fun |
💌 Sin 3: Ghosting Mary Linton
Listen, Arthur’s journal doesn’t lie—he’s still head-over-boots for Mary. Refusing her missions? That’s cold. Beyond crushing our boah’s heart, you’re locking out:
-
The Saint-Denis date (his happiest moment!)
-
Unique dialogue about their past
-
Zero alternatives; it’s her or nada!
Art by u/WestElizabethGurl on Reddit - Arthur gazing at Mary’s photo
🐴 Sin 4: Neglecting Your Horse
This one’s personal. Your horse? That’s family. Starving it, skipping brushes, or not reviving it after a tumble? Straight-up villainy. Why? Because:
-
Bonding levels boost stamina/health 🏃
-
That death scene? I still cry!
-
Real cowboys cherish their steeds—period.
People Also Ask: "Can horses really bond with Arthur?" Heck yeah! They nuzzle you, follow commands smoother, and panic less in gunfights.
👦 Sin 5: Antagonizing Jack Marston
Four words: Don’t bully the kid. Whether it’s toddler Jack or teen Jack, hurling insults feels disgusting. Think about his tragic arc—born into outlaw life, watching everyone die trying to save him. Dutch’s gang was his only stability, and Arthur/John were his protectors. Taunting him? That’s kicking a puppy that’s already been kicked by fate.
So why do these "sins" matter? 🤔 Is it about preserving Arthur’s legacy, or do they reveal how deeply we empathize with pixels? Maybe RDR2’s real magic is making us feel like honor isn’t just a meter—it’s choosing kindness in a cruel world. What’s your unforgivable sin? Let’s debate below! 👇